For a first purchase, low minimums and a straightforward buying experience matter more than shaving the last fraction of a percent off premium.
For a first purchase, the biggest practical factors aren't necessarily the lowest possible premium — they're a low or no minimum order, straightforward site navigation, and enough review volume to feel confident the company is legitimate. We've weighted this list accordingly rather than purely on price.
There's no requirement to make a large first purchase. Starting with a single coin or a small junk silver order to get comfortable with the buying, shipping, and (eventually) selling process is a completely reasonable way to build confidence before committing more significant funds.
Read through our safe buying checklist before placing your first order, regardless of which dealer you choose — verifying the dealer independently and understanding shipping insurance takes a few extra minutes and meaningfully reduces risk.